Individual 18-hole scores
| Score | Name | Date | Tournament | Course |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 70 | Lauren Campbell | 10/6/2011 | MIAA Jamboree #4 | Bedford Valley Country Club |
| 71 | Casey Lamp | 4/7/2013 | Washington U. Invitational | Gateway National Golf Links |
| 71 | Casey Lamp | 4/14/2016 | Illinois Wesleyan Spring Fling | Ironwood Golf Course |
| 72 | Lindsay Pipkin | 4/5/2009 | Trine Invitational | Zollner Golf Course |
| 72 | Lauren Campbell | 10/8/2011 | MIAA Championship | Bedford Valley Country Club |
| 72 | Theresa Damico | 9/20/2012 | MIAA Jamboree #1 | The Medalist Golf Club |
| 72 | Nicole Deweyert | 10/2/2019 | MIAA Jamboree #3 | Zollner Golf Course |
| 73 | Adrienne Plourde | 9/7/2012 | Olivet Fall Invitational | The Medalist Golf Club |
| 73 | Adrienne Plourde | 4/16/2014 | MIAA Playoff #1 | Blackthorn Golf Club |
| 73 | Casey Lamp | 3/12/2016 | George Fox Westbrook Invitational | Westbrook Village Golf Course |
| 74 | Linday Pipkin | 9/27/2006 | Aquinas Invitational | Scott Lake Country Club |
| 74 | Megan Rimmel | 4/9/2008 | MIAA Playoff #1 | Zollner Golf Course |
| 74 | Trisha McKim | 5/16/2006 | NCAA DIII Championships | Centennial Oaks Golf Club |
| 74 | Lindsay Pipkin | 9/6/2008 | Anderson Invitational | Killbuck Golf Course |
| 74 | Amber Conrod | 9/20/2008 | MIAA Jamboree #2 | Zollner Golf Course |
| 74 | Amber Conrad | 9/12/2009 | Olivet Fall Invitational | The Medalist Golf Club |
| 74 | Amber Conrad | 4/17/2011 | Illinois Wesleyan Spring Fling | Ironwood Golf Course |
| 74 | Lauren Campbell | 9/2/2011 | NCAA Preview | Zollner Golf Course |
| 74 | Lauren Campbell | 9/10/2011 | Olivet Fall Invitational | The Medalist Golf Club |
| 74 | Theresa Damico | 9/21/2011 | MIAA Jamboree #2 | The Ravines Golf Club |
| 74 | Theresa Damico | 3/17/2013 | Jayll Island Classic | Indian Mound Golf Club |
| 74 | Adrienne Plourde | 4/27/2013 | MIAA Playoff #3 | The Medalist Golf Club |
| 74 | Theresa Damico | 8/31/2013 | Labor Day Tee-Off | The Medalist Golf Club |
| 74 | Adrienne Plourde | 9/1/2013 | Labor Day Tee-Off | The Medalist Golf Club |
| 74 | Adrienne Plourde | 9/7/2013 | Olivet Fall Invitational | The Medalist Golf Club |
| 74 | Casey Lamp | 4/11/2015 | Illinois Wesleyan Spring Fling | Ironwood Golf Course |
| 75 | Amanda Sanders | 4/20/2008 | Illinois Wesleyan Spring Fling | Ironwood Golf Course |
| 75 | Amber Conrad | 9/7/2008 | Anderson Invitational | Kilbuck Golf Course |
| 75 | Megan Rimmel | 9/23/2009 | MIAA Jamboree #2 | Macatawa Golf Course |
| 75 | Lauren Campbell | 4/14/2010 | MIAA Playoff #1 | The Medalist Golf Club |
| 75 | Abby Wheeler | 10/9/2010 | MIAA Fall Finale | Bedford Valley Country Club |
| 75 | Lauren Campbell | 9/3/2011 | NCAA Preview | Zollner Golf Course |
| 75 | Adrienne Jones | 10/8/2011 | MIAA Championship | Bedford Valley Country Club |
| 75 | Theresa Damico | 9/16/2012 | Illinois Wesleyan Fall Classic | Ironwood Golf Course |
| 75 | Theresa Damico | 3/16/2013 | Jekyll Island Classic | Indian Mound Golf Club |
| 75 | Adrienne Plourde | 9/16/2013 | O'Brien National Invitational | Warren Golf Course |
| 75 | Adrienne Plourde | 10/5/2013 | MIAA Jamboree #4 | Zollner Golf Course |
| 75 | Adrienne Plourde | 10/11/2013 | MIAA Fall Finale | Bedford Valley Country Club |
| 75 | Adrienne Plourde | 4/6/2014 | Washington U. Invitational | Gateway National Golf Links |
| 75 | Casey Lamp | 9/6/2015 | Labor Day Tee-Off | The Medalist Golf Club |
| 75 | Nicole Deweyert | 10/7/2017 | MIAA Fall Finale | Bedford Valley Country Club |
| 75 | Nicole Deweyert | 8/23/2019 | Trine Fall Kick-Off Classic | Zollner Golf Course |
Individual 36-hole scores
| Score | Name | Date | Tournament | Course |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 149 | Lauren Campbell | 9/2-9/3/2011 | NCAA Preview | Zollner Golf Course |
| 149 | Casey Lamp | 3/12-3/13/2016 | George Fox Westbrook Invit. | Westbrook Village Golf Course |
| 149 | Casey Lamp | 4/16-4/17/2016 | Illinois Wesleyan Spring Fling | Ironwood Golf Course |
| 150 | Lauren Campbell | 10/7-10/8/2011 | MIAA Fall Finale | Bedford Valley Country Club |
| 150 | Adrienne Plourde | 9/7-9/8/2012 | Olivet Fall Invitational | The Medalist Golf Club |
| 150 | Theresa Damico | 8/31-9/1/2013 | Labor Day Tee-Off | The Medalist Golf Club |
| 151 | Amanda Sanders | 4/19-4/20/2008 | Illinois Wesleyan Spring Fling | Ironwood Golf Course |
| 151 | Amber Conrad | 9/9-9/7/2008 | Anderson Invitational | Killbuck Golf Course |
| 151 | Lindsay Pipkin | 4/4-4/5/2009 | Trine Invitational | Zollner Golf Course |
| 151 | Amber Conrad | 9/11-9/12/2009 | Olivet Fall Invitational | The Medalist Golf Club |
| 151 | Adrienne Plourde | 8/31-9/1/2013 | Labor Day Tee-Off | The Medalist Golf Club |
| 152 | Megan Rimmel | 9/5-9/6/2009 | Anderson Invitational | Killbuck Golf Course |
| 152 | Lauren Campbell | 9/9-9/10/2011 | Olivet Fall Invitational | The Medalist Golf Club |
| 152 | Theresa Damico | 9/15-9/16/2012 | Illinois Wesleyan Fall Classic | Ironwood Golf Course |
| 152 | Adrienne Plourde | 10/11-10/12/2013 | MIAA Fall Finale | Bedford Valley Country Club |
| 153 | Lindsay Pipkin | 9/27-9/28/2008 | DePauw Small College Classic | Deer Creek Golf Club |
| 153 | Adrienne Plourde | 9/15-9/16/2012 | Illinois Wesleyan Fall Classic | Ironwood Golf Course |
| 153 | Adrienne Plourde | 4/5-4/6/2014 | Washington U. Invitational | Gateway National Golf Links |
| 154 | Lindsay Pipkin | 9/6-9/7/2008 | Anderson Invitational | Killbuck Golf Course |
| 154 | Megan Rimmel | 9/19-9/20/2009 | Illinois Wesleyan Fall Classic | Ironwood Golf Course |
| 154 | Theresa Damico | 9/15-9/16/2013 | O'Brien National Invitational | Warren Golf Course |
| 155 | Theresa Damico | 10/7-10/8/2011 | MIAA Fall Finale | Bedford Valley Country Club |
| 155 | Casey Lamp | 9/5-9/6/2014 | Olivet Fall Invitational | The Medalist Golf Club |
| 155 | Nicole Deweyert | 9/6-9/7/2019 | Kyle Campbell Memorial | The Medalist Golf Club |
| 156 | Kristy Latimer | 4/15-4/16/2005 | Illinois Wesleyan Spring Fling | Ironwood Golf Course |
| 156 | Adrienne Plourde | 9/6-9/7/2013 | Olivet Fall Invitational | The Medalist Golf Club |
| 156 | Nicole Deweyert | 10/6-10/7/2017 | MIAA Fall Finale | Bedford Valley Country Club |
| 157 | Lindsay Pipkin | 9/2-9/3/2006 | Ferris State Bulldog Invitational | Katke Golf Course |
| 157 | Lauren Campbell | 9/5-9/6/2009 | Anderson Invitational | Killbuck Golf Course |
| 157 | Amber Conrad | 4/10-4/11/2010 | DePauw Invitational | Twin Bridges Golf Course |
| 157 | Hayley Cooper | 4/16-4/17/20116 | Illinois Wesleyan Spring Fling | Ironwood Golf Course |
| 157 | Laura Bacso | 9/9-9/10/2016 | Kyle Campbell Classic | The Medalist Golf Club |
| 157 | Laura Bacso | 4/8-4/9/2017 | Washington U. Invitational | Norman Probstein Golf Course |
Individual 54-hole scores
| Score | Name | Date | Tournament | Course |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 231 | Theresa Damico | 3/15-3/17/2013 | Jekyll Island Collegiate Classic | Indian Mound Golf Club |
| 235 | Brooke Kastamo | 3/13-3/15/2015 | Jekyll Island Collegiate Classic | Indian Mound Golf Club |
| 241 | Adrienne Plourde | 3/14-3/16/2014 | Jekyll Island Collegiate Classic | Indian Mound Golf Club |
| 241 | Nicole Deweyert | 3/17-3/19/2017 | Jekyll Island Collegiate Classic | Indian Mound Golf Club |
| 243 | Theresa Damico | 3/16-3/18/2012 | Jekyll Island Collegiate Classic | Indian Mound Golf Club |
| 245 | Lauren Campbell | 3/16-3/18/2012 | Jekyll Island Collegiate Classic | Indian Mound Golf Club |
| 246 | Theresa Damico | 3/14-3/16/2014 | Jekyll Island Collegiate Classic | Indian Mound Golf Club |
| 246 | Laura Bacso | 3/13-3/15/2015 | Jekyll Island Collegiate Classic | Indian Mound Golf Club |
| 247 | Adrienne Plourde | 3/15-3/17/2013 | Jekyll Island Collegiate Classic | Indian Mound Golf Club |
| 247 | Ashley Folleth | 3/17-3/19/2017 | Jekyll Island Collegiate Classic | Indian Mound Golf Club |
| 248 | Amber Conrad | 5/11-5/13/2011 | NCAA Division III Championships | El Campeon Golf Course |
| 248 | Adrienne Jones | 3/16-3/18/2012 | Jekyll Island Collegiate Classic | Indian Mound Golf Club |
| 251 | Lauren Campbell | 5/11-5/13/2011 | NCAA Division III Championships | El Campeon Golf Course |
| 252 | Brooke Kastamo | 3/14-3/16/2014 | Jekyll Island Collegiate Classic | Indian Mound Golf Club |
| 252 | Casey Lamp | 3/13-3/15/2015 | Jekyll Island Collegiate Classic | Indian Mound Golf Club |
| 252 | Laura Bacso | 3/17-3/19/2017 | Jekyll Island Collegiate Classic | Indian Mound Golf Club |
| 252 | Nicole Deweyert | 3/16-3/18/2018 | Jekyll Island Collegiate Classic | Indian Mound Golf Club |
| 254 | Ashley Stark | 3/14-3/16/2014 | Jekyll Island Collegiate Classic | Indian Mound Golf Club |
| 255 | Casey Lamp | 3/15-3/17/2013 | Jekyll Island Collegiate Classic | Indian Mound Golf Club |
| 255 | Allyson Schultz | 3/13-3/15/2015 | Jekyll Island Collegiate Classic | Indian Mound Golf Club |
| 259 | Casey Lamp | 3/14-3/16/2014 | Jekyll Island Collegiate Classic | Indian Mound Golf Club |
| 260 | Brooke Kastamo | 3/15-3/17/2013 | Jekyll Island Collegiate Classic | Indian Mound Golf Club |
| 261 | Abby Wheeler | 5/11-5/13/2011 | NCAA Division III Championships | El Campeon Golf Course |
| 261 | Crystal Lettinga | 3/16-3/18/2018 | Jekyll Island Collegiate Classic | Indian Mound Golf Club |
| 261 | Crystal Lettinga | 3/15-3/17/2019 | Jekyll Island Collegiate Classic | Indian Mound Golf Club |
| 261 | Ella LaMothe | 3/27-3/28/2026 | Lawrence Tech Invitational | Heritage Hills Golf Club |
Individual 72-hole scores
| Score | Name | Date | Tournament | Course |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 321 | Trisha McKim | 5/13-5/16/2008 | NCAA Division III Championships | Centennial Acres Golf Club |
| 326 | Lindsay Pipkin | 5/13-5/16/2009 | NCAA Division III Championships | PGA Golf Club of Port St. Lucie |
| 326 | Theresa Damico | 5/13-5/16/2014 | NCAA Division III Championships | El Campeon Golf Course |
| 328 | Lindsay Pipkin | 5/13-5/16/2008 | NCAA Division III Championships | Centennial Acres Golf Club |
| 328 | Amanda Sanders | 5/13-5/16/2008 | NCAA Division III Championships | Centennial Acres Golf Club |
| 328 | Megan Rimmel | 5/13-5/16/2009 | NCAA Division III Championships | PGA Golf Club of Port St. Lucie |
| 329 | Megan Rimmel | 5/13-5/16/2008 | NCAA Division III Championships | Centennial Acres Golf Club |
| 329 | Adrienne Plourde | 5/14-5/17/2013 | NCAA Division III Championships | Baytowne Golf Club |
| 330 | Amber Conrad | 5/13-5/16/2009 | NCAA Division III Championships | PGA Golf Club of Port St. Lucie |
| 333 | Lauren Campbell | 5/11-5/14/2010 | NCAA Division III Championships | El Campeon Golf Course |
| 334 | Kristy Latimer | 5/8-5/11/2007 | NCAA Division III Championships | El Campeon Golf Course |
| 334 | Amber Conrad | 5/13-5/16/2008 | NCAA Division III Championships | Centennial Acres Golf Club |
| 334 | Theresa Damico | 5/14-5/17/2013 | NCAA Division III Championships | Baytowne Golf Club |
| 336 | Lindsay Pipkin | 5/8-5/11/2007 | NCAA Division III Championships | El Campeon Golf Course |
| 340 | Amber Conrad | 5/11-5/14/2010 | NCAA Division III Championships | El Campeon Golf Course |
| 341 | Katie Misko | 5/13-5/16/2009 | NCAA Division III Championships | PGA Golf Club of Port St. Lucie |
| 341 | Megan Rimmel | 5/11-5/14/2010 | NCAA Division III Championships | El Campeon Golf Course |
| 341 | Brooke Kastamo | 5/13-5/16/2014 | NCAA Division III Championships | El Campeon Golf Course |
| 342 | Adrienne Plourde | 5/13-5/16/2014 | NCAA Division III Championships | El Campeon Golf Course |
| 343 | Casey Lamp | 5/13-5/16/2014 | NCAA Division III Championships | El Campeon Golf Course |